Kurt Gödel’s Story

It is my impression that, even among mathematicians, mathematical logicians are a bit weird. Kurt Gödel was no exception.

Gödel is famous for proving foundational questions about mathematics. He asked questions like, “Can I prove that math is consistent?” and, “If I have a true statement, can I prove that it’s true?” and, “Can I prove that it’s impossible to prove the statement ‘This statement is unprovable’ is provable?”

Yeah, not exactly the most obvious questions to ask, but important ones, I promise.

Gödel was born in 1906 in what is now Brno, Czech Republic, but was then in Austria-Hungary. His family called him Herr Warum (“Mr. Why”), which is impressive given how fond children everywhere are of that question.

By the time he went to the University of Vienna at 18, he had already mastered university-level math. During this time, he came across Russell’s work on the foundations of mathematics, and met Hilbert, who, around that time, was thinking deeply about axioms and logical systems, and whether it could be shown they had no contradictions, and whether all true statements could be proven.

By 23, Gödel finished his PhD in mathematical logic. Two years later, he published his seminal work on his incompleteness theorems. These papers have the answers to the questions I introduced, but I want to finish talking about Gödel. We’ll discuss the details next time.

Two years after that, in 1933, Gödel became a lecturer at the University of Vienna. He also traveled to the US, where he met Einstein, who became his good friend.

During this time, Hitler came to power in Germany. A few years later, the professor who had originally interested Gödel in logic was assassinated by one of his former students, essentially because he was friends with Jews.1 This caused a “nervous crisis” in Gödel. He became paranoid, fearing that he would be poisoned. These symptoms continued later in his life.

In 1938, Nazi Germany annexed Austria. Gödel’s job title was eliminated, so he had to apply to a new job. However, since he had been friends with Jews, they turned him down.

Things got worse the next year. Germany found him fit for conscription, and World War II began. Within the year, Gödel left for Princeton, at the Institute of Advanced Study, where Einstein was.

And, being Gödel, he decided that an Atlantic crossing was too much. So he took the obviously less strenuous route of a train ride across Russia to Japan, a boat ride across the Pacific, then another train ride to Princeton, New Jersey.2

He was very productive during his time in Princeton, proving some other results about the foundations of mathematics.

In 1947, Einstein took Gödel to his US citizenship exam. Gödel, being a constant logician, told Einstein he had discovered an inconsistency in the US constitution that could allow the US to become a dictatorship. Einstein was concerned… not about the possibility of a dictatorship, but that Gödel’s eccentric behavior might endanger his citizenship application.

Einstein was right to fear.

During Gödel’s hearing, the judge asked what kind of government they had in Austria. Gödel replied that it was a republic, but that the constitution was such that it was changed into a dictatorship. The judge expressed his regret, then said that this could not happen in this country.

Gödel replied, “Oh, yes, I can prove it.”

Fortunately, the judge was an acquaintance of Einstein’s, and said, “Oh God, let’s not go into this.”2

Anyway, Gödel kept on working. Among other things, for Einstein’s 70th birthday, Gödel created a spacetime which… breaks general relativity. Well, at least, it has all sorts of things go wrong. For instance, there are “closed timelike loops” through every point of spacetime, meaning that anyone and everyone can time travel. He also expanded Leibniz’s “proof” of God’s existence.

Later in his life, his paranoia recurred. He had an overwhelming fear of being poisoned, and would only eat food that his wife prepared for him. When she was hospitalized for 6 months, he refused to eat, eventually starving to death. At the time of his death, he weighed only 30 kilos.

In the next post, we’ll get to talk about Gödel’s completeness and incompleteness theorems, and come face to face with the inherent limitations of mathematics!

(For those of you who enjoyed this, you might also enjoy my articles on Georg Cantor and Karl Schwarzschild!)

<– Previous Post: Where do axioms come from?
First post in this series: What is math?
–> Next Post: Gödel’s Incompleteness Theorems

1.  Though Schlick was not a Jew, his murder became a cause of celebration, which fed the growing anti-Jewish sentiments in Vienna. When Germany annexed Austria, the murderer was released, having only served 2 years of a 10 year sentence.
2.  To be fair, his exit visa explicitly stipulated the trans-Siberian route. The Atlantic crossing was dangerous during the war. More details can be found here
3.  The constitutional problem that Gödel found was never recorded, but a good guess is that he was referring to Article V, which allows the constitution to be amended. Though it is very hard to pull off, you could, in theory, change the constitution to allow amendments relatively easily, say by a majority of both houses of congress. This is essentially what the constitution of the Weimar republic (pre-WWII Germany) said. Once the constitution is easy to change, it is a (relatively) simple matter to make the president a dictator. Germany’s Reichstag (congress) made Hitler a dictator in this way.

10 thoughts on “Kurt Gödel’s Story”

1. N G says:

To whom it may concern,

Interesting post. Thanks.

“The judge expressed his remorse, then* said that this could not happen in this country.”

Rgds,
N

Like

1. Dr. Dilts says:

Thanks for the catch!

Like

2. I was under the impression that it took a majority of the States to vote on any Amendments to the Constitution. So it would be very difficult for both houses of Congress to make the President a dictator.

Frankly, given our current political situation with the GOP kowtowing to President Trump, I pray that is true. His proclivity towards authoritarian comments and affinity for dictators makes thoughtful people nervous. There must be a check on Presidential power and the power of the majority to inflict its will on the minority.

Like

1. Dr. Dilts says:

That’s right. In one method, it takes 2/3 of the senate AND 2/3 of the states to make amendments. But there are those that have suggested that that process should be changed to, in the most extreme case, only requiring a 2/3 of the senate. If, after that change, 30 years later, 2/3 of the senate could be bribed to change the constitution to make someone a dictator. It requires two changes. The first makes it much easier, the second actually makes the person a dictator. It might even seem like an innocent change at first glance!

Like

3. Jay says:

Did he anticipate the cheating GOP in all branches of government and a senile paranoid President?

Like

4. Jen Browne says:

Surely you can only express remorse for a wrong you yourself did.
The judge would have expressed regret,not remorse.
He could only have expressed his remorse if he himself had contributed to turning the republic into a dictatorship.
Similarly those who did not vote for Trump deeply regret that he was somehow elected president.
Those who actually voted for him should feel remorseful.

Like

1. Dr. Dilts says:

Good catch. Thanks.

Like

5. Billnix says:

Seems America is doomed. I would recommend Americans apply for Russian or Chinese citizenship and emigrate before Trump owns America. They will need to soon. Luckily I live in Australia. The Chinese will soon give us passports, if we behave politely and allow them to buy anything they like in our country.

Like

6. Maybe he thought about the option of a second constitutional convention?

Like

7. Neil Spark says:

Interesting, intriguing and informative. Thank you for posting this. I hadn’t heard of Godell and I look forward to the next instalment.

Like